Saturday, December 13, 2014

The narcissist's quest for attention, his sense of entitlement, his expectation of admiration.


    In this follow-up post to the previous post, I compare my case to two articles written in regard to the Jian Ghomeshi case where he abused women and seemed to think it was completely acceptable. He even supplied the CBC with evidence to prove he was physically abusive. The first article is available in the November 24th edition of Maclean’s written by Trevor Cole whose father was a clinical narcissist. The second article covers the story of Ms. Borel who was hired as a producer at CBC’s Q and ended up quitting, and who described her experience to The Guardian recently (this article referred to in greater detail in following blog post). The Guardian revelation is covered in the National Post on December 3, 2014, A5.

   Building on top of the Rolling Stone description of campus tribunals, the CBC treatment of Ms. Borel also compares with my experience. My “Ghomeshi” is Jerry Kachur but to what degree this professor is comparable as a narcissist with Ghomeshi would require others who experienced his behaviour to tell their stories. I do not think Dr. Kachur is as serious a narcissist as Ghomeshi – he doesn’t appear in my experience to be into abusing women physically. Dr. Kachur does not appear to be devoid of feelings of compassion, but in my experience he is nonetheless a narcissist to the extent that abuse occurred and that abuse is what I experienced. Per Cole, “…the narcissist treats people cruelly.” In my story, written long before the Ghomeshi story, I describe Kachur as abusive with his knowledge, generally abusive, even sadistic. The kind of abuse is as well along the lines of Trevor Cole’s father, “…was a man very much like the disgraced CBC star. He didn’t share Ghomeshi’s sexual proclivities, but he was a performer, too; he flashed an equally practised smile for the camera, and he was governed by the same personality demons.” So far, Kachur isn’t in the media but he is flashing his smile for graduate students within his classes in Alberta and too when he travels to American universities to make presentations, at the time when I was a student, New Orleans (before the hurricane) Kachur had a loyal following. Trevor Cole’s article does describe the narcissist as I experienced – “The true narcissist is a more complex creature and, as we can see with Ghomeshi, more damaging. [My career was ruined] Essentially, he is an emotional toddler dressed in an adult’s sophistication. The child’s urgent ‘Look at me, Mommy!’ impulse drives the narcissist’s quest for attention, his sense of entitlement, his expectation of admiration.” According to what Kachur told me he was narcissistically denied as a baby (roots for emotional dysfunction rooted in infancy is outlined by author John Bradshaw in his various books) and somehow was afflicted with painful boils which had to be lanced and which caused him excruciating pain. Presumably this was a symbolic physical manifestation of the lack of motherly love and attention, and then the remedy for treating the boils also caused a kind of punishment for “feeling” and since babies experience emotions through their bodies, extensive physical pain is interpreted emotionally and creates anxious, vigilant, selfish adults. Per Dr. Kachur’s supposed academic dismissal when he was in Ontario in the 1990s presenting and channelling impending recession and a political swing to the right that ultimately did emerge under the leadership of Mike Harris, this seminal experience denied him the admiration he felt he deserved thus building hostility in respect of anything Ontarian and to which I was a really great object for his denial and punishment. Further Kachur as a suffering half Ukrainian is apparently entitled to abuse students regardless of standards set for public universities should it so suit him since he is a fifth generation Ukrainian in Alberta whose father was discriminated against and never achieved notoriety causing this only son to be highly motivated to succeed his father and also presumably to do his father’s dream. Dr. Kachur also was the product of a highly suffering woman, his mother, who fell off a hay bailer and was seriously scarred by burns. So scarred she was that she was outwardly hardened and through outward stiffness due to the skin, was inwardly emotionally unavailable. To my understanding the experience of this woman is a reflection of some kind of abuse that is submerged and cannot be revealed and is indicative of some kind of secret, possibly sexual, that is hidden from this powerful man, whose sister was an anorexic and who appears to be a possible recipient of the abuse to which he is unconscious. The model is there and the professor is channelling it. The emotional story and the generational story (not the least of which is European in origin) create the narcissistic personality and the problems I encountered are related to the story. According to this man I was not entitled to be a professor because I had SES, social economic status through my father. In checking the first few pages of the Master’s thesis I put into his  mail box after signing it out in my own name for a term loan from the library stacks of University of Alberta, Dr. Kachur saw in my acknowledgements (not reading any further) and the recognition of the death of my father due to prostate cancer and the fact that he had been a teacher at Durham College in Oshawa, and to this Dr. Kachur construed that I was not going to be free to study even though on my own with minimal resources I put everything into place with which to be a valid student at the PhD level. A year or so ago, I sent ten years of tax assessments to this man proving that I did not enjoy SES in my own family which included my son and two cats. My understanding is that Dr. Kachur didn’t like the fact that my father was more educated than his father and that his father had suffered as a consequence of his lack of status since he was Ukrainian whereas my father was British and so therefore I needed to be punished and denied. In an email I defended my father as a product of working class England and as suffering as any other minority relative to the clear class divide in that country. My father was intelligent and achieved excellent marks in mathematics and physics at Carleton University in Ottawa, and became an engineer, however, he never felt legitimate as a “middle class” Canadian and suffered enormously as a consequence of abuse by his uneducated mother in his childhood and the loss of his father at fourteen, but no suffering was to be permitted to me, however, in this Kachur was transcendent and thus entitled to submissive prostrations by underling students, above all others. Dr. Kachur was allowed to cite his suffering as a source for his special status and entitlement. And then I was the eldest daughter of three girls and carried the productive tendency described by John Bradshaw as a mantle for the eldest, especially eldest sons except that there were no sons so I filled that role as the eldest because my father taught us a lot of things that fathers didn’t traditionally teach daughters. He became sexist when we became young women, but when we were children he taught us things that fathers reserve for boys. Due to this influence I didn’t really understand myself as a second-class citizen as a female to be denied access to possibilities until my University of Alberta experience. And for this aspect of my personality, Dr. Kachur would accuse me of being “aggressive” and deny me the momentum built into me by all those aspects that created my personality, including perfectionism and ambition. I would be punished by him while he would be entitled to pursue his ambition while at the same time denying students under him, particularly women, of whom there were numbers that were perhaps greater in percentage due to the fact that it was public education, teaching, traditionally a second-class job reserved for women. And due to this focus, this man relative to so many men in this career area have traditionally entered into public education due to class issues (no resources or models that encourage entry into the higher professions) and enjoyed satisfaction overseeing and controlling women teachers, earning salaries as principals, administrators, school supervisors etc. (in the commission reports the commissioners many of whom are employed in the public education system carve out supervisory positions for themselves in recommendations post commission) – for example traditionally, principals were male and teachers in the primary grades were always women and they remained as teachers and were never promoted to any higher positions. When Kachur cited to me that feminism is only twenty years old, which I consider a lot of nonsense and a statement of ignorance, Kachur was perhaps also interpreting the traditional purpose of graduate studies, where the studies trained men to enter into the public school system as principals who would oversee women teachers. Advances by women into the role of principalship was perhaps at the time Kachur made the statement only twenty years in practice. Well, a lot of time has passed since he made that statement to me, so at this time of writing I would prefer not to delve into the matter of time passing, since is a function of the abuse I received and a point of great pain in my story since Kachur’s attitude and error and ignorance ruined my career and left me in poverty with a huge student loan and no dignity or even a smidgen of social status, living in a room rented to me by a biker and feeling a little scared, this after having to leave Ontario in order to counter the legal claim for the student loan. I miss my son who I had to leave because I didn’t have work in Ontario because I have a B.Ed from Alberta which is why I returned to studies in Alberta, to which Frank Peters an immigrant from Ireland didn’t give me any consideration after a cash grab had been achieved in concert with the agenda of his colleague Gerry Taylor and others, to study in Alberta.

   Kachur was impatient and diminishing in his comments. He found all students stupid and he was particularly unhappy when dealing with intelligent women since he suffered/suffers from feelings of inadequacy. To quote Cole on his father, a performer, “But, from any early peak, his career withered. His delusions of grandeur, combined with the deep insecurity common in narcissists, meant he stopped auditioning for new roles.” Cole’s father said people knew he was talented where in fact people couldn’t stand him. Well, I don’t know what was going on in and between professors in the department, but I think it was nasty and backstabbing. Kachur wanted to be the top intellect and he didn’t like Alison Taylor who was writing books on provincial public education policy. He didn’t like women and their involvement meant in his purview a reduced value of his own credentials. He was highly concerned about credential inflation. I described Kachur as charming and charismatic in my rendering of my experience long before the Ghomeshi scandal. The fact of the matter is that I ended up in the cross-hairs of this professor as a woman to be blocked because I was a full time student and was studying full time because I was interested in ultimately working as a professor and Kachur and his colleagues do not want women with my personality and outward representation advancing to such. A feminist would have had to take me “under her wing” and there weren’t any available in policy. This Kachur understood and he began to undermine me in subtle and not so subtle ways. First of all he attributed my Master’s thesis to another author. I believe that this was a genuine error he made because as a sociologist he really didn’t care very much for public education policy understanding such policy as a kind of second-class text within a second-class “soft” (i.e. education compared to sociology, where sociology is not soft) genre. It sure looked and still looks to me that this man earned a PhD in the department but only after achieving employment realized that he didn’t know what public education policy in Alberta consisted of and did a cursory post-hire review of some policy products of the province, particularly the Worth Report which content and jaundiced writing caused him to hold his nose and repudiate the genre in total. I don’t think Kachur reviewed the Cameron Report or some of the documents I make available in my research. This in part due to the problem of the invention of the department as Foundations specifically designed to the training of teachers, a response to post 1960s teacher shortage. Since Alberta was a new province in 1905 the 1960s Cameron Report was a foundational document putting in place teacher training as the foundational orientation in provincial public education policy and distorting the matter of public education as foundational rather than a response to the products of public government on public government as foundational (commissions not teacher training). Technically Kachur didn’t know what was going on and he didn’t really want to know because he couldn’t stand the genre. The Saskatchewan reports are/were particularly simple and dismissible such that Kachur in presumably being exposed to them as a Master’s student at the University of Saskatchewan determined that policy as he understood it was a particularly gross and substandard product, although he seemed to be interested in Ontario’s public education products and criticized me for not doing any research on Ontario policy. I said I didn’t choose to review any Ontario policy because “big heads” were doing that, and although I didn’t name any names, I meant Jerry Paquette, Derek Alison, and Bob Gidney. And even though these men practice at the University of Western Ontario and are not at the highly touted OISE, in fact, these three are key provincial public education policy analysts are often cited in commission reports and other literature. In the 1994 Ontario commission report Rebecca Coulter, a woman professor, feminist, and public education policy analyst is cited more than once. On the other hand, I had realized as a Master's student that there was no review of Northwest Territories public education policy, at the time I was doing research a 1990s policy product had just been produced – People: Our focus for the future, a strategy to 2010 – and the key policy document of the 20th century Tradition: Learning and Change in the Northwest Territories (1982) had a counterpoint which provided a point for comparison. Due to Dr. Kachur`s prejudice and ignorance, really, this project was deleted as a valid research project by him even though it was approved and passed by the Ontario policy analysts just named. The research I spent so much concentrated time on as a product of dedication and belief in excellent work and genuine engagement was construed to be already accounted for in the literature and I was sent to the back of the line by Kachur and his superior Gerry Taylor who seems to have been responsible for my admission to the department but who didn’t seem to think my Master’s thesis was valid even though it was signed off by two specific analysts, Paquette and Alison. Gerry Taylor, who appears to have reviewed applications for admission but not to the extent where he reviewed my Master’s thesis and denied me admission as a consequence of its apparent, to him, substandard quality. He could have denied me admission also due to lack of expertise to the research I proposed, which involved reviewing curriculum history and other aspects of curriculum formation in the northwest Territories/Nunavut. Therefore Gerry Taylor was totally into cash grab because either way (re: “this thesis stinks” and/or “we don’t have the expertise to oversee this research proposal”) I was not denied admission – none of that mattered, what mattered was the cash grab. In particular Gerry Taylor and his behaviour helps to crate the “byzantine system” described by the journalist reviewing Ms. Borel’s experience working for CBC’s Q and trying to cope with the problem of Ghomeshi’s abuse, and aligning with the attitude of sexism and abuse that I experienced as a doctoral candidate. I am now hated and blocked by professors making huge amounts of money for such abuses, while I owe in excess of fifty thousand dollars, forty thousand lent to me by the Province of Ontario and the Government of Canada.

  Educational Policy Studies, University of Alberta, may I have some justice please?

 

0 Comments:

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home